Witchella was a significant part of the women's basketball program from 2011-2015. In her three seasons as a Pioneer, she played in 73 games and left quite the mark in the history books.
She leads the program in points (1331), rebounds (988), rebounding average (14.7), defensive rebounds (692), offensive rebounds (405), defensive rebounds per average (9.5), offensive rebound average (5.55), field goals made (531), field goals attempted (1197), free throws made (259), free throws attempted (442), blocks (247), steals (169) and games started (72).
She is second in blocks per game (3.4), third in scoring average (17.8) and steals per game (2.3), fourth in field goal percentage (.440) and minutes (1738), fifth in games played (73) and eighth in assists (88) and minutes per game (29.8).
Witchella is also in the history books for individual game records. She leads the program in rebounds (31, at IWCW; 3/4/2015), free throws made (13, at SUNY Canton; 1/31/2015) and free throws attempted (16, twice). She is also in the Top-10 for most points (29), field goals made (13), field goals attempted (26), free throw percentage (.813), steals (5) and blocked shots (7).
After her performance in 2014-15 she tops the record books in single season points (538), scoring average (20.7), free throws made (119),free throws attempted (186), rebounds (381), rebounding average (14.7), defensive rebounds (229), defensive rebound average (8.8), offensive rebounds (152), offensive rebound average (5.8), steals (74), games played (26), is second in field goals made (209) field goal attempts (433), steals average (2.8), is third in field goal percentage (.483), blocked shots (68), blocked shots average (2.6).
Witchella is the second Lady Pioneer to earn All-American honors from the USCAA. She was named first team USCAA All-American and named to the all-tournament team at the National Championships in 2014-15.